Analytics ·

Drip Campaign Analytics: What to Measure and How to Compare It

How to measure drip campaigns: the metrics that matter, how to set up holdouts and cohorts, which tools handle sending, testing and data, and what Drip costs at common list sizes.

By the editorial team

For most drip campaigns, the best starting pick for measuring results is Drip. Its workflows and dynamic segments let you split a sequence into comparable groups inside the same tool that sends the emails, and the plan for 1 to 2,500 people is $39 a month on monthly billing, with a 14-day trial that needs no credit card. That matters for analytics because a number only means something when you can say exactly who received which email, when they received it, and how they compare with a group that did not. The rest of this guide covers which numbers to track, how to set up fair comparisons, how the main tools in this category differ on price and limits, and when a second tool earns its place.

Who this guide is for

This is written for teams that already run, or are about to run, a sequence of scheduled emails: onboarding for new users, a trial-to-paid nurture, an abandoned-cart series, a win-back flow, or a renewal reminder. These teams usually have one question that a dashboard does not answer on its own: which emails are doing work, and which are just being sent. Answering that takes three things. You need a defined goal, a clean group of people who entered the sequence, and a way to compare them with a baseline. The metrics below are only useful once those three are in place.

Start with the question, not the dashboard

Before you open any report, write down four decisions in plain language:

  • The primary outcome. One event that counts as success, such as a first project created, a paid upgrade, or a completed checkout. Pick one. Secondary outcomes can be tracked, but they cannot decide whether the sequence works.
  • The review window. How many days after enrollment a person can still count as converted. A 7-day window and a 60-day window will give different answers, and a sequence that runs for 14 days should not be judged on conversions that happen in month three without a note explaining it.
  • The entry rule. Who qualifies to enter. If the rule is "signed up for the newsletter", the group is very different from "started a trial and added a payment method". Mixing them produces averages that describe nobody.
  • The comparison group. Either a holdout (eligible people who are deliberately not emailed, usually a random slice of 5 to 10 percent) or a pre-sequence baseline (the same people's behavior before they entered). A holdout is more trustworthy because it controls for seasonality and product changes that happen at the same time as the sequence.

Without a holdout, every improvement will look like the sequence's doing. With one, you can say how much of the outcome the emails actually moved, which is the number finance and product leaders usually want.

The four metric groups

It helps to sort metrics into four groups so that no single number is asked to do everything:

  • Delivery and health tells you whether mail is reaching inboxes and whether people are leaving. Bounces, complaints and unsubscribes live here.
  • Engagement tells you whether people are paying attention. Opens, clicks and replies live here, with the caveats covered below.
  • Outcome tells you whether the sequence achieved its goal. Conversion rate and time to conversion live here.
  • Value tells you what the sequence is worth. Revenue per email, revenue per enrolled person and retention effects live here.

Review them in that order. A campaign with a bounce problem will show distorted engagement, and a campaign with weak engagement rarely produces a clean outcome figure. Looking at value first, without checking delivery, is the most common way teams end up with a revenue number they cannot defend.

Which tool does what

Most teams combine two or three products. A sending platform records what was sent and to whom, a workflow or data tool moves events between systems, and a testing tool measures the pages that emails send people to. The table below compares the tools that come up most often in this setting. Prices are the ones published on each vendor's pricing page at the time of checking; where a vendor publishes no figure, the table says so.

Tool Best for Entry price (plan and billing) Key limitation
Drip Running drip workflows and segmenting by person, so each sequence has a clear cohort $39/month for 1 to 2,500 people, monthly billing; 14-day trial, no card needed No ongoing free plan is shown; the price rises with the number of people
Sender Small lists that need a free starting point Free Forever: 2,500 subscribers and 15,000 emails a month. Standard: $6.30/month for 6,000 emails a month The paid tiers list a 500-subscriber allowance, which limits larger lists
Make Moving send, click and purchase events into a spreadsheet or warehouse for custom reports Free: 1,000 credits a month. Core: $10.59/month, or $9/month billed annually, for 10,000 credits The free plan allows 2 active scenarios, and a scenario can run at most every 15 minutes
Convert Testing the landing pages and offers that emails link to Growth: $399/month, or $299/month billed annually, for 100,000 monthly tested users No free plan; a 15-day trial on the paid plans
Segment (Twilio Segment) Collecting first-party events across products and sending them to other tools Pricing on request. No free-plan limits or prices are published Costs cannot be estimated from the public page, so a quote is needed before budgeting

Drip

Drip suits teams whose main question is "which people went through which sequence, and what did they do next". Its workflows let you build a multi-step sequence with branches, and its dynamic segments keep the membership of a group current as people's attributes change. Those two features are what make cohort analysis practical: you can define "people who entered the onboarding workflow in March and have not yet created a project" and watch that group over time without exporting it by hand.

The listed plans include unlimited email sends, dynamic segments and onsite campaigns, with up to 50 workflows on the entry tiers. Larger tiers add chat and email support, and the highest tiers on the page add a fixed send allowance (for example, 600,000 email sends on the 45,001 to 50,000 people tier) rather than unlimited sends. The price is set by the number of people in your account, which is the main thing to plan around. A list that grows steadily will move up a tier, and the monthly bill will move with it.

Where Drip falls short for analytics is that the public pricing page does not describe how deep its reporting goes. Treat the trial as the test. Build one real sequence, run it for the full review window, and check whether you can answer your primary outcome question without exporting data. If you cannot, the gap is worth knowing before you sign up, because it determines whether you need a second tool. There is also no ongoing free plan, so a small team that wants to experiment for months at no cost will need a different starting point.

Sender

Sender is the practical choice when the list is small and the budget is zero. The free tier allows 2,500 subscribers and 15,000 emails a month, which is enough to run a basic welcome sequence and measure its opens and clicks. The paid Standard tier is listed at $6.30 a month for 6,000 emails a month, and Professional at $10.50 a month for 12,000 emails, both with a 500-subscriber allowance on the published page. The subscriber limit is the constraint to check first. If your list is bigger than that allowance, the monthly price no longer tells you the real cost.

For analytics, Sender is a reasonable place to learn the basics: how a sequence is built, how opens and clicks are reported, and how to set a holdout. The limitation to plan for is that outcome tracking, such as a paid upgrade recorded in your billing system, usually has to be connected from outside the email tool. That is where a workflow tool like Make comes in.

Make

Make is not an email platform. It is an automation tool that moves data between systems, and it matters here because the most valuable outcome data often lives in a product database or billing system rather than in the email tool. A typical setup is a scenario that watches for a purchase or a feature event, looks up whether that person received a sequence email in the previous 14 days, and writes a row to a spreadsheet or warehouse. The sequence can then be judged on conversions that really happened after an email, not on conversions the email tool guessed at.

The free plan gives 1,000 credits a month, with no time limit, and each module action in a scenario uses one credit. That is enough for a small test, but two active scenarios and a 15-minute minimum run interval are real constraints if you need near-real-time reporting. The Core plan, listed at $10.59 a month on monthly billing or $9 a month billed annually for 10,000 credits, removes the active-scenario limit and adds scheduling down to the minute. The price shown is for 10,000 credits; the credit allowance can be raised on a slider, so the bill depends on how many actions your scenarios run.

Convert

Convert is a testing platform, and its place in this discussion is narrow but important. Drip emails are often judged on the click, but the business result happens on a page: a pricing page, a checkout, a booking form. If you change the offer in the email and the page at the same time, you cannot tell which change moved the outcome. Convert measures tests on the landing pages themselves, using monthly tested users as its unit of billing.

The Growth plan is listed at $399 a month on monthly billing, or $299 a month billed annually, for 100,000 monthly tested users. The Pro plan is listed at $599 a month, or $420 a month billed annually, with more segments and advanced features. There is a 15-day trial on both, and no free plan. Convert is a good fit for teams with enough traffic to a landing page that a test can reach a readable result within the review window. For a small list that only sends a few hundred visitors a month to a page, the tool will not give you a clean answer, and a simple before-and-after comparison with a holdout will be more honest.

Segment (Twilio Segment)

Segment is a customer data platform. It collects events from websites, apps and servers and routes them to other tools. For a drip analytics setup, it is most useful when the same person is active in several products and you need one consistent identity for them across all of those events. The pricing page does not publish costs for its tiers; the page describes a free trial for Connections plans without stating its length or limits, and the enterprise-style tiers are priced on request. Budget for a quote, and ask specifically how the plan you choose counts events and identities, because that is what drives the bill.

Segment is more infrastructure than most teams need for a single sequence. It earns its cost when the same question has to be answered across an email sequence, an in-app onboarding flow and a billing system at once.

What the cost looks like at real list sizes

Drip is the tool in this group with the clearest published price per list size, so it is the easiest to model. The table below uses the Drip tiers that contain each list size. Prices are monthly. The annual figure is simply 12 times the monthly price; it is not a discount, because the Drip pricing page does not list an annual rate for these tiers.

Active people Drip tier Monthly price Twelve months at monthly billing
2,500 1 to 2,500 people $39 12 × $39 = $468 a year
5,000 4,501 to 5,000 people $89 12 × $89 = $1,068 a year
10,000 9,001 to 10,000 people $154 12 × $154 = $1,848 a year
25,000 22,501 to 25,000 people $369 12 × $369 = $4,428 a year

The table makes one planning point clear: the step from 2,500 people to 5,000 more than doubles the monthly price, and the price keeps climbing with the list. If you run a holdout of 10 percent, you still pay for those people, because they are in the account. Build the holdout into your cost forecast rather than treating it as free.

For comparison, a list of 2,500 subscribers fits within Sender's Free Forever allowance, provided the monthly email volume stays under 15,000. That is the realistic starting point for a small team. Once the list passes the point where the paid Drip tier starts to make sense, the question becomes whether the extra workflow and segment features are worth the difference, and the answer depends on how many sequences you run and how often you change them.

The metrics that matter, with the caveats

Open rate

Open rate is the share of delivered emails that were recorded as opened. It is the metric most affected by privacy changes. Apple Mail Privacy Protection can record an open when the mail app loads images in the background, which can happen without the person reading anything. Because of this, use open rate as a trend line for a single sequence, compared against that sequence's own history, rather than as an absolute measure of interest. Compare like with like: the same entry rule, the same send time and the same mailbox mix.

Click rate and click-to-open rate

Click rate, the share of delivered emails that contained a click, is generally more trustworthy than open rate because a click requires a deliberate action. Count unique clicks per person and treat repeat clicks separately, since one person clicking the same link five times tells you something different from five people each clicking once. Click-to-open rate (clicks divided by opens) can help diagnose the content for people who did open, but it inherits the open problem in its denominator. It is most useful when paired with an outcome metric and a defined review window.

Reply rate

For sequences that ask a question or come from a named person, replies are often the most informative engagement signal. A reply tells you the message got a human response, and replies can carry objections and questions that a click never reveals. Track replies by message and by the intent segment that received it. There is no universal reply-rate target that applies across industries, so set the baseline from your own history for the same audience and offer.

Sequence conversion rate

This is the central outcome metric, and it is simple to calculate:

Conversion rate = (people who completed the goal within the review window) ÷ (people who entered the sequence) × 100

Suppose 1,000 people enter an onboarding sequence and 80 of them create a first project within 14 days. The conversion rate is 80 ÷ 1,000 × 100 = 8 percent. That number only means something against a comparison. If the holdout of 100 people who were eligible but not emailed produced 4 projects in the same window, the holdout rate is 4 percent, and the sequence's estimated lift is 4 percentage points. The sequence did not create all of the 8 percent; the holdout shows what would have happened anyway.

Set the entry rule and the goal so that they match. A trial-to-paid sequence should only count people who started a trial in the same period, with the same activation definition, and a cart-recovery sequence should only count carts that were abandoned after entry. A conversion rate calculated across mixed entry rules will look healthy or weak for reasons that have nothing to do with the emails.

Email-level contribution

Once the sequence-level number is trustworthy, look at which emails are carrying it. The usual method is to attribute a conversion to the last email a person clicked, or to the last email received before the goal event, and count how many conversions each email is credited with. Be explicit about the rule, because it changes the answer. An email that sits near the end of a sequence will often look strong under a last-click rule simply because people who are already close to converting reach it.

Time to convert

Time to convert shows how long after enrollment the goal is reached. Plot the cumulative share of conversions by day. If most conversions happen before the third email, later emails may be adding little, or they may be reaching the people who needed the most nudging. The curve tells you where to look, but you still need the holdout to know whether the later emails caused the late conversions.

Unsubscribe rate

Unsubscribes after a single email are a useful signal, but they need a baseline. Set an alert from your own history for the same sequence and the same sending cadence, and treat a spike on one message as a specific problem to investigate. Three patterns usually mean different things:

  • A spike on one specific email points to that message's content, timing or promise.
  • A consistently elevated rate across the whole sequence points to frequency or targeting.
  • A rate that is higher than your one-off promotional emails points to a sequence-specific mismatch, such as people who entered without expecting a series.

Spam complaints and bounces

Complaints affect sender reputation, so any meaningful increase deserves attention the same day. Common causes are an unclear unsubscribe path, content that does not match what people signed up for, and people who have forgotten they opted in. Never add purchased or scraped addresses to a sequence.

Bounces come in two kinds. Hard bounces are addresses that cannot receive mail and should be removed at once. Soft bounces are temporary failures that can be retried a few times before the address is suppressed. Track them separately. A sustained rise usually points to the acquisition source that brought in the bad addresses, to a form that accepts typos, or to a suppression rule that has stopped working.

Revenue per email

Revenue per email (RPE) is the total revenue attributed to a sequence divided by the number of emails sent:

RPE = attributed revenue ÷ total emails sent

Illustratively, a sequence that sends 12,000 emails and is credited with $4,200 of revenue has an RPE of 4,200 ÷ 12,000 = $0.35 per email. RPE lets you compare sequences of different lengths, but it can flatter short sequences that send few emails and only work on high-intent people. Pair it with revenue per enrolled person, which divides attributed revenue by the number of people who entered, to see whether a sequence is worth its audience.

Retention and lifetime effects

A sequence can convert fewer people in the first two weeks and still produce customers who stay longer. Measure this by comparing retention curves for the sequence group and the holdout over several billing cycles, not just at the goal. This is the number that most often changes a decision: a sequence that looks weak on conversion can be the best one for keeping customers after the first month.

Setting up comparisons that hold up

The analysis is only as good as the cohort definitions behind it. Set these up before the sequence goes live:

  • Record the entry event with a timestamp, so every person can be placed in a cohort by the week or month they joined.
  • Assign the holdout at entry, using a random split, and store the assignment in the same record as the entry event. Assigning it later, after you have seen early results, introduces bias.
  • Carry a message identifier on every link in the sequence, so that a click or a purchase can be traced back to a specific email.
  • Define suppression rules for people who purchase, reply, unsubscribe or enter a competing journey, and record when they were removed. A person who buys in the first week should not keep receiving reminders that count as a sequence failure.
  • Document the attribution window and the rule, so that a future analyst can reproduce the number.

Refunds and cancellations need a rule too. If a person converts to paid and cancels within the first 30 days, decide whether that counts as a conversion, and apply the same rule to the holdout. Otherwise the sequence will look better than it is whenever it brings in people who leave quickly.

From metric to decision

Most reports end with a list of numbers and no next step. The table below pairs the common patterns with the first thing to check and the usual action. Each row assumes that the delivery metrics are healthy; if they are not, fix delivery first.

What you see Check first Likely action
Opens are stable, clicks fall Whether the subject line promises what the body delivers Rewrite the body and the main call to action; keep the subject line
Clicks are stable, conversions are flat against the holdout Whether the landing page matches the email's promise Test the page, or change the offer in the email to match it
Unsubscribes spike on one email Content, timing and the email's position in the sequence Shorten or move the email; remove a repeated claim
Unsubscribes are high across the whole sequence Cadence and entry rule Space the emails further apart, or narrow who enters
Conversions cluster in the first few emails Whether later emails reach a different group Shorten the sequence, and test whether the later emails add anything against the holdout
Hard bounces rise Which acquisition source or form brought in the addresses Add address validation at the form and suppress the addresses already in the list
Lift looks large but the holdout is small Sample size in each group Wait for the review window to close and enough people to enter before deciding

Setup steps for the first analysis

The first analysis of a new sequence takes longer than the later ones, because you are building the definitions. Work through the steps in order, and record the output of each one in a shared document, so that the next person can rebuild the report.

Step What to record When
1. Write the primary outcome and review window One event, a number of days, and the reason for both Before launch
2. Define the entry rule and the holdout size The qualifying event, the holdout percentage, and the assignment method Before launch
3. Tag every link with a message identifier The identifier format and where it is stored Before launch
4. Confirm suppression rules with a test person Which events remove a person and when Before launch
5. Pull delivery and health metrics weekly Bounces, complaints and unsubscribes by message Weekly from launch
6. Compare the sequence group with the holdout Conversion rate for each group and the difference between them After the review window closes
7. Attribute conversions to emails The attribution rule used, and the count per email After the review window closes
8. Decide and record the change What changed, the date, and the result to check next time After each analysis

Interpreting a funnel without fooling yourself

A funnel view shows how many people reach each email and how many of them do something after it. Here is an illustrative funnel for a five-email onboarding sequence that started with 1,000 people:

  • Email 1: 1,000 entered, 980 delivered, 390 opened, 52 clicked
  • Email 2: 940 delivered, 330 opened, 41 clicked
  • Email 3: 905 delivered, 300 opened, 47 clicked, 19 completed the goal
  • Emails 4 and 5: 851 and 809 delivered; 7 more goal completions in the window

The drop between email 2 and email 3 in clicks is small, but the goal completions after email 3 are the sign that the sequence is working for the people who reach it. The illustrative numbers do not prove that email 3 caused those completions; a holdout does. What the funnel does show is where the sequence loses people, which is the question to ask before you change anything.

Cohort views are the next step. Compare people who entered in January with those who entered in December, and check whether a change to email 3 altered the curve only for people who entered after the change. Segment views are useful when the audiences are truly different, such as new trial users and existing customers, but they multiply the number of comparisons. Each extra cut raises the chance of finding a difference that is not real, so decide on the segments before you look at the results.

How to choose

Pick the tool that answers your primary question with the least extra infrastructure. The sequence of decisions below is a reasonable order:

  • If the list is small and the budget is zero, start with Sender's free tier, build the sequence, and set up a manual holdout in a spreadsheet. Check the subscriber allowance first.
  • If you need cohorts and workflows and the list is in the low thousands, Drip's entry tier at $39 a month is the simplest starting point, with a 14-day trial to confirm the reporting covers your question.
  • If outcomes live in your product or billing system, add a workflow tool such as Make to join those events to the email send records. Start on the free tier to prove the join works before paying for more credits.
  • If the sequence sends people to pages you are already testing, add Convert only when enough visitors reach the page for a result to be readable within the review window.
  • If the same person is active across several products, a customer data platform such as Segment becomes worth a quote, because identity consistency is the hard part of the analysis.

Avoid buying a second tool to fix a problem that the first tool's setup could solve. Most early analytics failures come from undefined entry rules, missing holdouts and mixed review windows, and none of those is solved by more dashboards.

Frequently asked questions

What is the single most important metric for a drip campaign?

The sequence conversion rate against a holdout, measured on your primary outcome within a fixed review window. Engagement metrics explain why the number moved, but this is the number that says whether the sequence achieved its goal.

How big should a holdout group be?

Many teams start with 5 to 10 percent of eligible people. A smaller holdout keeps more people in the sequence but gives a noisier comparison. Choose the size before launch, keep it fixed, and wait until enough people have entered for the difference to mean something before acting on it.

Can I trust open rates at all?

Yes, as a trend for the same sequence over time. Privacy features distort opens, so do not compare absolute open rates across different audiences or mailboxes, and do not use them alone to judge a sequence. Clicks and outcomes are more reliable.

What does Drip cost for a list of 10,000 people?

The 9,001 to 10,000 people tier is listed at $154 a month on monthly billing, which comes to $1,848 over twelve months at that rate. The pricing page does not list an annual rate for this tier, so the twelve-month figure is simple multiplication. Check the tier boundaries on the pricing page before you sign up, because the price moves at each band.

Is Sender's free plan enough to measure a sequence?

For a small list, it can be. The free plan allows 2,500 subscribers and 15,000 emails a month, which covers a basic welcome or onboarding sequence. You will still need a way to record outcomes outside the email tool, and a manual holdout is workable at small scale.

Why does my revenue number differ from what the email tool reports?

Email tools typically credit revenue using their own attribution rule, such as a click within a set window, while your billing system records the actual payment. The difference is usually the attribution rule and the window. Document the rule you use, reconcile it with billing at least once a month, and treat any revenue figure as an estimate of the sequence's contribution rather than a precise total.

When should I stop a sequence that is underperforming?

Stop when the holdout comparison shows no lift after the review window has closed, enough people have entered to rule out a small difference, and the delivery and health metrics are clean. Stopping earlier, based on a few days of data, is the most common reason teams abandon sequences that would have worked.